Below are nine organizational and writing tips to help you write the best critical analysis essay possible. 1. Read carefully and carefully. You will need to accurately represent an author's point of view, A CRITICAL REVIEW OF QUALITATIVE INTERVIEWS. Ali Alsawi. University of Newcastle, New Castle Upon Tyne, United Kingdom. Email: aas855 hotmail.com. ABSTRACT. his article is a critical assessment of the merits. Fundamental Research Module I – critical evaluation. Health care. 1. Critical Assessment – ​​Download as PDF or view online for free. Critical evaluation is a writing task that asks you to summarize and evaluate a text. The review can relate to a book, a chapter or a journal article. Writing the review usually requires that you read the selected text in detail and read other related texts so that you can present a fair and reasonable assessment of the selected text.